Top Stories

Trend Alert: Cheesy Scalloped Potatoes Surpass Mashed Favorites

Trend Alert: Cheesy Scalloped Potatoes Surpass Mashed Favorites
Editorial
  • PublishedNovember 22, 2025

URGENT UPDATE: A new culinary trend is emerging as food enthusiasts eagerly ditch traditional mashed potatoes for cheesy scalloped potatoes this Thanksgiving. With the average cost of hosting a Thanksgiving dinner soaring to $431 in 2023, families are aiming for dishes that deliver both flavor and value.

This shift has been ignited by a popular recipe from Half Baked Harvest, created by acclaimed cookbook author Tieghan Gerard. Home cooks are raving about the rich, creamy layers of potatoes combined with caramelized onions, making this dish a must-have on holiday tables.

The recipe features Yukon Gold potatoes, known for their buttery texture, which are sliced thinly and layered with a blend of heavy cream and whole milk. The preparation begins by preheating the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit and caramelizing onions in butter, a step that fills kitchens with an irresistible aroma.

Cooks are advised to add 2 cups of heavy cream, 1 cup of whole milk, and a dash of cayenne to enhance the flavors. After assembling the layers in a 9×13-inch baking dish, the dish is covered with foil and baked for two hours, creating a bubbling, savory masterpiece.

After the initial bake, a topping of shredded cheddar cheese is added, and the dish is returned to the oven for an additional 20 minutes to achieve a golden crust. This final touch elevates the entire dish, offering a perfect contrast between creamy potato layers and a crispy cheesy top.

Notably, this shift from mashed potatoes to scalloped varieties resonates with many who find traditional mashed potatoes lackluster. One enthusiast shared, “The texture and flavor are far superior to even the best mashed-potato recipe,” emphasizing the growing consensus among food lovers.

This culinary switch is not only about taste but also about making the most of Thanksgiving gatherings. With rising costs, families want to ensure every dish is memorable and satisfying. The scalloped potatoes have become a focal point, showcasing the importance of flavor and presentation during the holiday season.

The trend is gaining traction on social media, with countless images and testimonials flooding platforms as families prepare for their Thanksgiving feasts. As this new favorite gains popularity, the emotional connection to the dish is palpable, with many sharing stories of how this recipe has transformed their holiday traditions.

For those looking to impress their guests this Thanksgiving, the cheesy scalloped potatoes from Half Baked Harvest are poised to take center stage. As preparations ramp up, be sure to check out the full recipe and ingredient list to make your holiday dinner unforgettable.

Stay tuned for more updates on this trending dish and see how it continues to reshape Thanksgiving menus across the globe.

Editorial
Written By
Editorial

Our Editorial team doesn’t just report the news—we live it. Backed by years of frontline experience, we hunt down the facts, verify them to the letter, and deliver the stories that shape our world. Fueled by integrity and a keen eye for nuance, we tackle politics, culture, and technology with incisive analysis. When the headlines change by the minute, you can count on us to cut through the noise and serve you clarity on a silver platter.