Fantasy Hockey Draft Strategy: Top Picks for Rounds 1 and 2

As the fantasy hockey season approaches, managers are gearing up for the annual draft, and player projections are essential tools in building a competitive team. These forecasts provide valuable insights into potential player performance, helping managers select the most effective roster possible. While the data is informative, personal judgment and intuition also play significant roles in decision-making. Here are the top 20 draft selections for Rounds 1 and 2, tailored for ESPN’s default points league.
Top Fantasy Picks in Rounds 1 and 2
The first few picks are critical, as they often set the tone for the entire draft. Among the elite skaters, Cale Makar stands out as the premier defenseman. Last season, he tallied an impressive 30 goals and 62 assists, leading all players in points during head-to-head standard points competition. The only factor possibly affecting his selection is the expectation for him to replicate such an extraordinary performance. If you believe he can maintain this level, don’t hesitate to select him early.
Following Makar, Kirill Kaprizov of the Minnesota Wild is a prime candidate for an early pick. During the first 34 games of the 2024-25 season, he recorded 23 goals and 27 assists before injuries curtailed his campaign. Now fully fit and recently signing a lucrative contract, Kaprizov is poised for a standout season, making him a compelling choice.
In the goaltending arena, Connor Hellebuyck of the Winnipeg Jets is a key player to consider. As the reigning Hart and Vezina Trophy winner, he accumulated approximately 20% more fantasy points than his nearest competitor last season. His performance is closely linked to his team’s success, so any decline in the Jets’ play could affect his numbers. Nevertheless, he remains a top-tier selection among goalies.
Another forward to watch is William Nylander, who followed a near 100-point season with 84 points in the last campaign. With Mitch Marner now absent from the roster, Nylander is expected to take on a more significant role, increasing his scoring opportunities. His shooting rate is also anticipated to rise, potentially making him a valuable asset in the draft.
Emerging Talents and Reliable Performers
The New Jersey Devils’ captain, Jack Hughes, represents a high-risk, high-reward option. After two injury-plagued seasons, he appears to be in excellent shape for the upcoming regular season. Hughes possesses the talent to exceed 100 points if he can stay healthy, making him a worthwhile gamble for managers looking for elite production.
On the other hand, Filip Forsberg of the Nashville Predators continues to deliver value, finishing in the top 15 for fantasy points despite a challenging season for his team. With expectations for a more robust performance this year, Forsberg could flirt with the 50-goal mark, making him an attractive option at the 13th overall pick.
As the draft unfolds, MacKenzie Weegar emerges as one of the NHL’s most versatile fantasy contributors. Despite not exceeding 50 points last season, his all-around play and durability make him a solid addition, particularly in leagues that reward physicality.
For those considering a second-tier goaltender, Tampa Bay’s Andrei Vasilevskiy is a strong candidate. While he is currently undergoing treatment and has missed practice, his track record as a reliable goaltender places him as a leading option if healthy.
As the NHL season kicks off on October 7, the landscape of fantasy hockey will evolve rapidly. Managers are encouraged to remain flexible, adapting their strategies based on player performance and team dynamics throughout the season. Drafting will be a blend of informed decision-making and personal instincts, ensuring a competitive league environment where every point counts.
This season promises excitement, and with the right picks, managers can build teams poised for success. For those ready to engage, ESPN offers a platform to create custom leagues and enjoy the thrill of fantasy hockey.