Netflix’s ‘Death By Lightning’ Revives Forgotten Political Drama
Netflix’s new four-part drama, Death By Lightning, explores the largely overlooked historical events surrounding the assassination of James A. Garfield, the 20th President of the United States. The series, inspired by Candice Millard’s acclaimed book, Destiny of the Republic: A Tale of Madness, Medicine and the Murder of a President, delves into the political landscape of the late 19th century and the violent act that cut short Garfield’s presidency.
Garfield, portrayed by Michael Shannon, was a president with progressive ideals who had ambitions to reform the government and champion civil rights. His leadership was tragically cut short when he was shot by Charles Guiteau, a mentally unstable man, just months into his presidency in 1881. The series brings to light both Garfield’s vision for America and the chaotic political climate that surrounded his rise to power.
Unpacking Political Tensions of the Era
The series begins with a snapshot of the 1880 Republican National Convention, a pivotal moment when the party was divided into two factions: the corrupt Stalwarts and the reform-minded Half-Breeds. Powerful figures, including New York Senator Roscoe Conkling, aimed to place former President Ulysses S. Grant back in office, while Half-Breeds were torn between supporting James Blaine and John Sherman. Garfield, initially only meant to nominate Sherman, emerged as a consensus candidate after a grueling thirty-six rounds of voting.
Showrunner Mike Makowsky expressed his surprise at Garfield’s story, noting that it felt relatable to modern audiences. He highlighted Garfield’s commitment to civil reform and equality, which he believes would have shaped a transformative presidency had it not been cut short. “I was blown away by both him as a human being and a potentially generational leader who we were tragically robbed of,” Makowsky stated.
Garfield’s marriage to Lucretia Garfield is another focal point of the series. As one of the first First Ladies to graduate from college, Lucretia played a significant role in her husband’s political life. “Crete,” as she was known, is portrayed as a key advisor, reflecting the evolving role of women in politics during that era. Makowsky emphasized her potential impact on Garfield’s presidency, which he believes would have elevated the responsibilities of First Ladies.
Contemporary Parallels and Themes
“It felt so immediate to this current era in which we live,” Makowsky said, drawing parallels between Garfield’s time and contemporary politics.
The series explores themes of political violence and mental health, particularly through the lens of Guiteau’s character. His obsession with Garfield and the subsequent assassination highlight the darker aspects of political ambition and disillusionment.
Guiteau, played by Matthew Macfadyen, is depicted not as a sympathetic figure but rather a tragic one, whose mental health struggles led to his violent actions. “In no way does the show seek to be an endorsement or glorification of political violence,” Makowsky clarified. Instead, the narrative aims to shed light on the factors that contribute to such acts, encouraging viewers to understand the underlying issues of alienation and rejection.
The series also addresses how Garfield’s death was not merely a result of the gunshot wound but from inadequate medical care. The poor treatment he received, which led to sepsis, serves as a grim reminder of the era’s medical practices and the fragility of life.
“Death By Lightning is riveting, fascinating television full of incandescent performances and complex questions about the nastiness of politics,” Makowsky noted.
With powerful performances from its cast, including Shannon and Macfadyen, the series is poised to attract significant attention during awards season.
As Death By Lightning streams on Netflix, its exploration of a forgotten chapter in American history, combined with its relevant themes, provides both entertainment and a poignant reflection on current political dynamics. Viewers are left with a deeper understanding of not only Garfield’s tragic story but also the broader implications of political violence and the struggles faced by those on the margins of society.
