Yankees Face Tough Choice: Re-sign Bellinger or Keep Grisham
The New York Yankees are approaching a significant decision regarding their outfield as both Cody Bellinger and Trent Grisham head toward free agency. With the 2025 MLB season behind them, the Yankees are contemplating whether to retain both players or choose one. ESPN’s Jeff Passan has made a compelling case for why the Yankees should prioritize re-signing Bellinger, labeling it the “perfect transaction” for Brian Cashman, the team’s general manager.
New York’s outfield demonstrated strong performance last season, led by Aaron Judge, a consistent MVP favorite. Bellinger and Grisham also contributed significantly, with both players showcasing their skills. However, as free agency looms, the Yankees are faced with the reality that keeping both may not be feasible. Passan emphasized that if Grisham declines the qualifying offer, center field would represent a critical gap for the team.
In reviewing their 2025 statistics, Bellinger outperformed Grisham. Bellinger ended the season with a batting average of .272, hitting 29 home runs and driving in 98 runs, resulting in an .813 OPS. In contrast, Grisham posted a .235 average with 34 home runs, 74 RBIs, and an .811 OPS. While both players had commendable seasons, Bellinger’s overall contributions, particularly his elite defensive skills in center field, make him a more valuable asset to the Yankees.
Should the Yankees opt to retain Bellinger, they will likely need to allocate a considerable budget, given their already high payroll. Nonetheless, Bellinger’s potential to become the team’s full-time center fielder aligns with their needs moving forward. The possibility of Grisham accepting the qualifying offer remains, though it is viewed as unlikely, further complicating the Yankees’ decision-making process.
As Bellinger approaches the off-season as a free agent, his performance this past season marked a significant resurgence since his 2019 MVP campaign. Although reaching that level consistently may be challenging, the combination of his defensive prowess and offensive capabilities makes him a prime candidate for the Yankees to keep.
In conclusion, as the Yankees navigate their options in the upcoming free agency period, the focus will be on whether to re-sign Bellinger or explore the potential of retaining Grisham. With Passan’s strong recommendation, the New York franchise seems poised to make a choice that could shape their future competitiveness in Major League Baseball.
