U.S. Court Rules Against Scotts Valley Casino Bid in Vallejo
UPDATE: The U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia has officially ruled against the Scotts Valley Band of Pomo Indians’ attempts to challenge the Department of the Interior’s reconsideration of their proposed casino project in Vallejo. This critical decision, made on Thursday, October 19, 2023, paves the way for a thorough review of the project, which could ultimately lead to permanent revocation of the tribe’s gaming eligibility.
The proposed casino, which would span 400,000 square feet and cost an estimated $700 million, is designed to include not only gaming facilities but also residential units and a biological preserve. However, the court’s ruling suggests that the project faces significant hurdles. The Department of the Interior is now empowered to assess all evidence regarding the land’s eligibility for gaming, including considerations that may impact local environmental and cultural resources.
Yocha Dehe Wintun Nation, a neighboring tribe, opposes the casino, claiming it threatens ancestral lands and vital ecological areas. Chairman Anthony Roberts stated, “Today’s court decision correctly reaffirms the Department of the Interior’s decision to reevaluate this proposed casino, which would destroy irreparable cultural and ecological resources.” He emphasized that the historical connection claimed by Scotts Valley to the land is unfounded, asserting, “Scotts Valley has no historical connection to this land.”
This ruling comes after a contentious history surrounding the proposed casino. The Department of the Interior initially greenlit the project in January 2023, a decision met with widespread opposition from local tribes, residents, and government officials, leading to the current reconsideration process. The court criticized the DOI for not notifying Scotts Valley before revoking its gaming eligibility, but clarified that this does not hinder the ongoing reconsideration.
Scotts Valley is now faced with the decision to appeal this ruling, with Chairman Shawn Davis asserting, “We will not allow bureaucrats trample our sovereignty.” Despite their strong stance, the court’s ruling indicates that reliance on the previous approval may be misguided.
Local reactions to the casino project have been mixed. While some residents express concerns about potential crime and environmental degradation, others see it as an opportunity for economic growth. Former business owner Kimberly Pelham noted the potential for increased tourism and local business revenue, stating, “Imagine people coming across from the ferry, bringing their money, gambling for the night.”
As the situation unfolds, attention will turn to Scotts Valley’s next steps and the ongoing impact of the court’s decision. The Department of the Interior’s review process is expected to take time, but the implications of this ruling resonate immediately for both the Scotts Valley Band of Pomo Indians and the surrounding Vallejo community.
Stay tuned for further updates on this developing story.
