Local News Decline Fuels Government Secrecy, Urgent Study Reveals
URGENT UPDATE: A groundbreaking study by the Brechner Center for the Advancement of the First Amendment at the University of Florida confirms a direct link between the decline of local news and a surge in government secrecy. Released just hours ago, the findings reveal alarming trends that could jeopardize democracy as we know it.
The study indicates that communities lacking robust local news outlets experience significantly less government transparency. As David Cuillier, director of the Freedom of Information Project, states, “Where there are no newspapers and weakened newspaper systems, government secrecy is flourishing.” This stark warning underscores the critical role local journalism plays in holding officials accountable.
Key data from the report shows that more than 3,300 local newspapers and 45,000 newspaper journalists have disappeared in the U.S. since 2005, marking a catastrophic 33% loss in newspapers and a staggering 60% drop in journalist numbers. This erosion of local news outlets has led to a dramatic increase in the denial of public records requests across the nation.
In a rigorous assessment, Cuillier and colleague Brett Posner-Ferdman analyzed responses to public records requests submitted to 44 state governments. Their findings reveal that states with fewer newspapers are more likely to deny or ignore these requests, with compliance rates hovering around 25%. In stark contrast, states with stronger press associations showed improved responsiveness.
The Medill Local News Initiative has tracked these troubling trends, highlighting a troubling reality: nearly half of the counties in “news deserts” did not respond to records requests. In many of these regions, local officials wield unchecked power, as underscored by former journalist Miranda Spivack, who noted that government secrecy often manifests in state and local levels where citizens most directly engage with governance.
“This is a terrible, terrible situation for democracy,” Cuillier warned, emphasizing that the lack of coverage emboldens public officials to withhold critical documents. Some counties, such as Slope County, North Dakota, with a population of just 740, have not seen any media requests in years, indicating a complete disconnect between citizens and their local governments.
The implications are dire. As Spivack documented in her book “Backroom Deals in Our Backyards,” government secrecy can lead to dire consequences, such as the concealment of hazardous materials and public health risks. She stated, “It paralyzes communities in a lot of ways,” placing immense power in the hands of officials and private companies.
To combat this crisis, Cuillier proposes several solutions, including strengthening local news ecosystems and implementing laws that mandate penalties for agencies that improperly withhold documents. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press is already taking steps to address this issue through its Local Legal Initiative, providing legal support to local journalists.
Eric Feder, director of the initiative, emphasized that legal action can yield immediate results. “Bringing a lawsuit gets results,” he stated, highlighting the need for persistent pressure on government entities to ensure compliance with transparency laws.
As this urgent situation unfolds, communities across the nation must recognize the critical connection between vibrant local news and effective government oversight. Without immediate action, the decline of local journalism may continue to exacerbate government secrecy, fundamentally undermining democratic principles.
Stay tuned for further developments on this critical issue as communities and advocates push for renewed transparency and accountability in government.
