Red Sox Fan’s Hot Mic Moment Critiques David Hamilton at Fenway
Fenway Park became an unexpected stage for a candid critique of Red Sox player David Hamilton during a recent game against the New York Yankees. On the evening of September 13, 2025, a fan seated on the iconic Green Monster was caught on camera expressing his frustration with Hamilton’s performance, providing an unscripted moment that added a humorous twist to the broadcast.
In the bottom of the seventh inning, the Apple TV coverage switched to a shot of the fan, who appeared to have enjoyed a few beverages throughout the game. This coincided with a moment when the game commentators were silent, creating a perfect opportunity for the fan’s comments to be aired live. “This guy should literally not even be in the league. How do we not have anyone better?” the fan lamented, wearing a vintage-style Red Sox hat and jacket.
The timing of the fan’s remarks was particularly poignant. At that point in the game, the Red Sox were struggling, still hitless against the Yankees. It wasn’t until the eighth inning that Nate Eaton hit a solo home run, providing the team’s first hit of the game. Ultimately, Boston lost to New York with a score of 4-1, managing only two hits throughout the match.
Hamilton’s at-bat was marked by a 1-2 count, leading to a strikeout on the next pitch. This left him with an 0-for-3 night, which further compounded the fan’s frustration. Following the game, Hamilton’s batting average stood at a disappointing .200, with a .568 OPS and only nine extra-base hits for the entire season. Despite being noted for his speed, he has struggled with stolen bases, having been caught six times in 26 attempts.
The situation is compounded by the fact that Hamilton was not the primary choice for the second base position this season. Craig Breslow, the Red Sox’s chief baseball officer, had anticipated that either Kristian Campbell or Marcelo Mayer would fill that role. However, Campbell was demoted to the minors following a poor start to the season, and Mayer sustained a season-ending wrist injury last month. This has led to heightened frustrations among fans and players alike at Fenway Park.
The candid remarks from the fan reflect the sentiments of many Red Sox supporters, who have witnessed a challenging season. While Hamilton may be facing significant scrutiny, the team is navigating a series of obstacles that have impacted its performance. As the Red Sox aim to regroup, it remains to be seen how they will address their lineup challenges and improve their standing in the league.
