NYPD Commissioner Rejects National Guard Deployment in NYC
New York Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch has expressed strong opposition to the idea of deploying the National Guard for law enforcement duties in New York City. During a recent address at a Citizens Budget Commission Breakfast in Midtown Manhattan, Tisch stated she is “revolted” by the thought of militarizing the city’s streets. Her remarks come in the context of a broader discussion about federal intervention in urban policing, particularly as the Department of Homeland Security prepares to target undocumented individuals in cities like Chicago.
The discussion about potential National Guard deployments in Democratic-led cities has gained attention following their use in Washington, D.C.. The Trump administration is reportedly weighing similar actions in New York after a deployment in the capital resulted in over 2,120 arrests, including those of 20 alleged gang members associated with MS-13 and the Venezuelan group, Tren de Aragua.
In her speech, Tisch emphasized the capabilities of the NYPD, asserting, “We don’t need or want the federal government’s help here in that way.” She underscored that NYPD officers are specifically trained to manage the complexities of urban crime, stating, “National Guard, God bless them, they are not trained to handle street crime in New York City.”
Tisch’s comments reflect a growing tension regarding federal involvement in local law enforcement. The situation in Washington, D.C. has already led to legal challenges. Last Thursday, D.C. Attorney General Brian L. Schwalb filed a lawsuit aimed at blocking what he termed the federal government’s “illegal deployment” of National Guard troops.
As of now, the emergency order authorizing the National Guard’s presence in D.C. has expired, and no extension is expected. This means control of the Metropolitan Police Department will revert back to the district unless new measures are enacted. Reports indicate that House Republicans are advancing 14 different bills aimed at significantly expanding federal authority over D.C.’s justice system.
While most National Guard troops are set to depart, some support is anticipated to continue in Washington through the end of the year due to ongoing coordination agreements with local authorities.
The debate over federal involvement in local policing continues to unfold, with significant implications for cities grappling with crime and public safety concerns. As discussions progress, Tisch’s firm stance exemplifies the pushback against perceived overreach from federal authorities in urban law enforcement matters.
